Dive Brief:
- Researchers at the University of Massachusetts have published a new study raising the alarm regarding cyberattacks fraudsters can use to target ACH bank transfers, the university said Monday.
- The study, titled Credit Without Debit: Formal Verification of Banking Payment Systems, examined three new tactics hackers could have used to pilfer funds from unsuspecting banks and their customers, the university said.
- The researchers alerted the at-risk banks to the problem and said the attacks have not been replicable since then. They presented their findings during the ACM Conference on Computer and Communications Security on Monday, the university noted.
Dive Insight:
Researchers at the University of Massachusetts contended that hackers could exploit flaws in Nacha’s ACH transfer process. Nacha is the association that oversees the national automated clearing house for payments, setting rules and standards for bank-to-bank transfers.
Though Nacha’s operating rules allow financial institutions to authorize checks once and make provisional credit spendable before the other bank has determined whether to execute the debit transactions, the researchers found that this could result in available funds at one bank while the corresponding debit fails at the other bank.
“Our goal is to strengthen financial security,” University of Massachusetts Amherst Professor Taqi Raza said in a press release. “The way we strengthen it is we find the loopholes and tell the banks, ‘okay, fix this problem.’”
Raza co-authored the study with Ali Malik, a doctoral candidate in electrical and computer science at the university.
The researchers identified three “credit-without-debit” attacks used by fraudsters and classified them into three threat categories they called: “creditbleed,” “creditmint” and “creditreset.”
Creditbleed attacks involve initiating an ACH debit to a restricted account at another bank. Then, when the original bank fails to settle the bogus transaction, it will accumulate spendable funds for attackers to spend until the bank with the restricted account eventually reverses the transaction, the researchers said.
When connecting a new external bank account, banks usually require account holders to enter the correct amount of change used for micro-deposits to verify their ownership. But attackers using the creditmint technique can trick banks into routing small deposits into restricted accounts that can’t send verification deposits back to the original bank, enabling fraudsters to repeatedly trigger those transactions and collect the spoils, the researchers explained in their study.
In creditreset attacks, hackers use debit-restricted bank accounts to falsely pay credit card payments and increase the card’s credit line. When the card issuer tries to collect funds from the bank, the transaction fails, allowing fraudsters to spend more on a higher credit line, according to the study.
The university declined to name which banks were affected by these disclosures, because “our work focuses on systematically identifying vulnerabilities in bank-to-bank transfers rather than individual institutions,” Raza said in an email. “The vulnerability disclosure to Nacha [is] handled through the banks; on checking, the reported issues appear to have been addressed in the updated Nacha specification.”
Nacha sees its accredited ACH professionals as mindful of the system’s parameters. They “are well versed in return risk – that an ACH debit can be returned for approximately two banking days for a number of reasons such as insufficient funds or frozen account,” a spokesperson for Nacha said by email. “Whether an originating bank or its ACH originating customer should allow funds from the debit to be withdrawn before the return deadline expires is their own call based on their own business needs and risk tolerances.”
UMass’ study comes as ACH payments have risen in popularity in recent years. In the third quarter, ACH Network payments jumped 5.9% year over year to 9.3 billion, according to an October Nacha press release. The value of those payments surged 10.2% from a year earlier to $25.6 trillion.
Meanwhile, major payments providers are tracking and bracing themselves for fraud attempts.
In its analysis of corporate and consumer fraud attacks released in May, Visa said it found roughly $1 billion in scam transactions in the second half of last year. Months later, the company acquired the cybersecurity and fraud-prevention company BioCatch for $2.4 billion to strengthen its anti-fraud offerings.